The City of London Corporation creates rules that look reassuring on paper while leaving residents to deal with the consequences of their apparent ineffectiveness.
By Doña Quixota

Two recent developments expose the growing crisis surrounding dockless e-bikes in the Square Mile: serious unanswered questions about an elected member’s commercial relationship with Lime, and the extraordinary revelation that the Corporation has not imposed a single charge under its P4 enforcement mechanism.
Together, they raise an uncomfortable question: is the Corporation regulating dockless bike operators in the public interest, or has it become far too accommodating of the companies it is supposed to oversee?
A Commercial Conflict at the Heart of the Corporation
Deputy Shravan Joshi MBE, a City of London elected member involved in transport-related decision-making, has taken a commercial advisory role with Lime, one of the principal operators whose activities the Corporation is responsible for overseeing.
The timing is particularly troubling.
Joshi participated in the July 2026 Streets and Walkways Sub-Committee deliberations concerning dockless cycle operators before subsequently taking up his advisory appointment with Lime. He also opposed the introduction of a third operator that would have competed with Lime.
This raises serious questions about the chronology of his commercial relationship with the company and whether any potential interest should have been disclosed earlier.
I raised these concerns directly with the Corporation’s Monitoring Officer, Michael Cogher.
His response was that Joshi had registered his Lime appointment as a disclosable pecuniary interest and that the law does not automatically prevent elected members from sitting on committees where a conflict may arise, provided they comply with the relevant restrictions on participation.
That may be an accurate explanation of the statutory framework. But it is not an answer to the questions I asked.
When did Lime first approach Joshi? Was he discussing a commercial appointment while participating in decisions affecting the company’s interests? Did his position on a potential third operator have any connection to his subsequent appointment? Has anyone independently examined that chronology?
Cogher concluded that there did not appear to be a breach of the Members’ Code of Conduct. His correspondence, however, did not establish that the relevant chronology had been independently investigated.
The Corporation’s own complaints procedure provides a mechanism for formal allegations to be assessed, with the possibility of an independent investigation and sanctions where a breach is established.
Registration of an interest is not a free pass that makes conflict of interest concerns disappear.
The issue is not whether elected members are entitled to earn money outside public office. The issue is whether a commercial relationship with a company directly affected by a member’s public responsibilities can compromise independent decision-making.
Joshi’s circumstances raise a serious potential conflict of interest that deserves independent scrutiny. Dismissing concerns without establishing the full chronology does little to reassure the public that commercial influence has been properly excluded from the Corporation’s decision-making.
An Enforcement Scheme With Zero Enforcement Charges
If the governance questions are troubling, the Corporation’s latest Freedom of Information disclosures are astonishing.
Its P4 enforcement mechanism provides for escalating charges of £2,500, £5,000 and £10,000 for successive qualifying defaults by dockless cycle operators.
Yet the Corporation has disclosed:
Zero P4 charges issued. Zero payments collected. Zero outstanding charges. Zero bicycles recorded as subject to P4 enforcement.
Not one.
Anyone walking through the Square Mile can see the daily reality: bicycles abandoned outside designated bays, pavements obstructed and pedestrian space increasingly surrendered to commercial fleets.
Are residents seriously expected to believe that this absence of penalties reflects flawless compliance by Lime and Forest?
There is a distinction between an improperly parked bicycle and a contractual default triggering a P4 charge. But that makes the Corporation’s failure to explain the figures all the more concerning.
Have the relevant thresholds never been breached, or have officers chosen not to impose charges? Who makes those decisions, and what evidence supports them?
If the Corporation maintains that no chargeable defaults have occurred, it should publish the underlying compliance data and demonstrate how that conclusion was reached.
An enforcement mechanism that never results in a charge is no more than an empty public relations exercise.
The Corporation Has Had Powers for Years
Another recent FOI disclosure makes the situation even harder to understand.
The Corporation supplied operational terms dating from October 2020 that contemplated extensive controls over dockless bike operators.
These included limits on the number of bicycles permitted in the Square Mile, restrictions on where operators could deploy them, removal deadlines for improperly parked bicycles and the ability to suspend or revoke operating approval for failures to meet the conditions.
The terms also required detailed monthly reporting on bicycle parking and real-time location data.
The Corporation has identified these as its pre-MoU operating arrangements, although the supplied document does not itself establish when Lime formally accepted the conditions.
The important point is that the City had contemplated extensive operational controls long before the current debate over new statutory licensing powers.
So what happened to enforcement?
Why have residents spent years navigating obstructed pavements while the Corporation continues to rely on arrangements whose effectiveness it has yet to demonstrate?
Private Profits, Public Costs
The Corporation’s financial disclosures add another dimension.
It has defended an £80-per-allocated-parking-space quarterly contribution as proportionate, without providing a sufficiently specific explanation in its latest FOI response of the underlying financial analysis.
At a time of significant pressure on public finances, the Corporation should be able to explain how it values commercial use of public highway space, how it monitors operator compliance and why its financial enforcement mechanism has produced no charges.
Why are commercial operators being allowed to occupy valuable public space while the Corporation struggles to demonstrate that its enforcement arrangements protect pedestrians or adequately recover public costs?
Private companies should not be permitted to externalise the costs of their operations onto residents, pedestrians and the public purse without effective accountability.
The Square Mile Is Becoming a Bicycle Landfill
The fundamental problem is increasingly impossible to ignore.
The volume of dockless bicycles circulating through the Square Mile far exceeds the capacity of the infrastructure available to accommodate them.
When fleets exceed practical parking capacity, pavement obstruction becomes a predictable consequence of the operating model.
Yet the Corporation continues to accommodate the operators, while pedestrians are expected to navigate the consequences.
The Square Mile is becoming a landfill for dockless bicycles: a place where commercial fleets accumulate across pavements, crossings and public spaces that were never designed to absorb them.
It is a disgrace that a local authority responsible for protecting the public highway has allowed the situation to deteriorate to this extent.
And when an elected member involved in transport policy also holds a commercial advisory role with one of the operators, questions about conflicts of interest become impossible to separate from questions about enforcement.
These circumstances do not establish corruption. But they raise legitimate concerns about potential commercial influence that should be investigated rather than brushed aside.
The Corporation must establish whether P4 defaults have occurred, explain why no charges have been imposed, disclose the evidence underpinning its enforcement decisions and, crucially, reduce permitted fleet sizes to levels that the existing parking infrastructure can realistically accommodate.
It must also ensure that the unanswered chronology of Deputy Joshi’s engagement with Lime is subject to appropriate independent scrutiny.
The City of London should not be a free storage facility for private e-bike companies, nor should its residents be expected to tolerate deteriorating public spaces while questions about commercial influence and regulatory accountability remain unanswered.
The public highway belongs to the public, not to Lime, Forest or any other commercial operator. It is time the Corporation started governing it accordingly.









